Do You Need To Handle Recursive Computations?

Optimizing Django’s Recursive Methods for Efficiency and Scalability

Photo by Tine Ivanič on Unsplash

Have you tried to write a recursive computation that examines a child value, which then examines a grandchild value, and so on, repeating the same structure until it hits the very bottom of the hierarchy with a valid value?

It’s a classic scenario in dynamic programming. A simple example is the Fibonacci sequence, where we resolve each value by looking back at its predecessors — a problem easily handled by memoization.

But what if the problem is far more complex? Imagine working within a framework like Django, where recursion spans multiple related models and sources, each with a different structure. Some records point back to themselves; others reference deeply nested relationships with entirely different models. This was exactly the problem I faced recently, and it drove me nuts.

In this article, we’ll tackle this problem by optimizing a Django method called get_origins, which pulls data recursively from various model sources. Initially implemented using a list-based approach, this method quickly grew inefficient for large datasets due to high memory usage and slow response times. By transforming it with generators, we’ll make the function more memory-efficient, faster, and capable of handling large datasets seamlessly.

The Problem with List-Based Methods in Complex Recursion

Here’s the original version of get_species that illustrates the challenges of using a list-based approach in Django’s recursive methods:

def get_origins(self):
    results = []
    for source in self.get_starting_sources():
        if source.library:
            library_origins = source.library.get_origins()
            if isinstance(library_origins, list):
                results.extend(library_origins)
            elif library_origins:
                results.append(library_origins)
        elif source.in_vivo_participant:
            results.append(source.in_vivo_participant.ext_origins)
        elif source.in_silico_participant:
            results.append(source.in_silico_participant.group_event.experiment.origins)
    return results

This version of get_origins collects origins data from various sources by building a results list, which it returns at the end. While effective in simple scenarios, this list-based approach quickly becomes inefficient in a recursive setup, as it holds all intermediate values in memory and delays the availability of results until the list is fully built.

Handling nested lists in recursive calls presents unique challenges, especially when it comes to flattening results into a single list. In get_origins, for example, we might encounter lists of origins from source.library.get_origins(), as well as individual origins results from in_vivo_participant or in_silico_participant. Concatenating these lists or values in each recursion quickly becomes cumbersome, requiring checks like isinstance(library_origins, list) to avoid appending nested lists instead of single elements.

Using yield from in place of appending lists simplifies this greatly. With yield from, each item in the nested list (or any iterable) is yielded individually, effectively flattening the result without needing additional code for checking list types. This not only makes the code cleaner but also improves performance by allowing each item to be processed as it's generated.

Generators to the Rescue

Generators provide an efficient way to manage large, recursive datasets without overloading memory. By yielding items one at a time, they allow us to handle each data point as it’s found, rather than waiting for the entire computation to finish.

Let’s refactor get_origins to use a generator, which yields results directly:

def get_origins(self):
    for source in self.get_starting_sources():
        if source.library:
            # Use `yield from` to handle lists, generators, or single values uniformly
            yield from source.library.get_origins()
        elif source.in_vivo_participant:
            yield source.in_vivo_participant.ext_origins
        elif source.in_silico_participant:
            yield source.in_silico_participant.group_event.experiment.origins

This version yields each origins value as soon as it’s found using yield and yield from. This approach improves memory usage, as only one result is held in memory at a time, and makes results available immediately.

Best Practices for Recursive Django Methods

When implementing recursive methods in Django, especially for complex relationships or large datasets, consider the following best practices to improve efficiency:

1. Use yield from for Simplifying Recursive Results

The yield from statement allows us to yield each item from an iterable directly, which is ideal for flattening recursive calls. In get_origins, we use yield from to yield items from each source's get_origins() call without needing to check if the result is a list or a single value.

2. Avoid Infinite Recursion by Tracking Visited Sources

In recursive methods, you need to prevent infinite loops, especially if a source could point back to a previously visited item. Track visited sources by using a visited set to mark each source as it’s processed.

def get_origins(self, visited=None):
    if visited is None:
        visited = set()
    if self in visited:
        return  # Prevent infinite recursion
    visited.add(self)
    # ...

3. Recursive Query Optimization: Avoid Redundant Queries with Caching

When calling recursive functions repeatedly, redundant queries can slow down performance significantly, especially if each call performs similar database queries. One way to handle this is by caching intermediate results so that previously retrieved data can be reused without querying the database multiple times.

Consider using a dictionary to cache results within each recursive call. Here’s an example:

def get_origins(self, cache=None):
    if cache is None:
        cache = {}

    if self in cache:
        # Return cached result if it exists
        yield from cache[self]
        return

    origins = []
    # ...
    # Cache the result for this instance to avoid redundant queries in future calls
    cache[self] = origins
    yield from origins

Here, the cache dictionary stores results for each instance as it’s processed. When an instance is revisited, we pull results directly from the cache instead of running additional queries. This optimization is particularly beneficial when data is deeply nested or has overlapping relationships.

4. Optimize Database Queries with select_related and exists()

Using select_related or prefetch_related can significantly reduce database hits, as they fetch related data in a single query. Additionally, using .exists() is faster than counting or retrieving full QuerySets, so use it to check for the existence of related records.

def get_origins(self):
    sources = self.get_starting_sources().select_related('library', 'in_vivo_participant', 'in_silico_participant')
    for source in sources:
        # Process as usual
        ...

Django QuerySets are lazy, meaning they don’t execute until evaluated. This aligns well with generators, as we can yield each item directly from a QuerySet without needing to load everything into memory first.

5. Provide Flexibility for Both Lists and Generators

By default, keeping the method as a generator provides memory efficiency. However, if you need a list, simply convert the generator to a list in the calling code:

origins_list = list(self.get_origins())  # Convert to list if needed

This flexibility allows you to choose the approach that best suits your needs, without compromising on memory efficiency.

Final Optimized Version

Here’s the final optimized version of the get_origins method, incorporating all the best practices discussed, including using yield from for recursion, tracking visited instances to prevent infinite loops, caching results to avoid redundant queries, and leveraging Django's lazy QuerySets.

def get_origins(self, visited=None, cache=None):
    # Initialize visited set and cache if they are not provided
    if visited is None:
        visited = set()
    if cache is None:
        cache = {}

    # Avoid infinite recursion by checking if this instance has already been processed
    if self in visited:
        return  # Stop recursion for this instance
    visited.add(self)

    # Check if results are already cached for this instance
    if self in cache:
        yield from cache[self]
        return

    # Initialize origins list to store intermediate results for caching
    origins = []

    # Fetch and iterate over starting sources
    for source in self.get_starting_sources().select_related('library', 'in_vivo_participant', 'in_silico_participant'):
        if source.library:
            # Recursively call get_origins on related library and pass cache and visited sets
            origins.extend(source.library.get_origins(visited=visited, cache=cache))
        elif source.in_vivo_participant:
            origins.append(source.in_vivo_participant.ext_origins)
        elif source.in_silico_participant:
            origins.append(source.in_silico_participant.group_event.experiment.origins)

    # Cache the results for this instance to avoid redundant queries in future calls
    cache[self] = origins

    # Yield each origins in the list
    yield from origins

Additional Use Cases for yield from

The yield from statement is versatile and can be applied to many other scenarios where recursive data processing or nested iterables are involved. For example:

• Tree-like Data Structures: If you have a hierarchy of objects (like categories with subcategories), yield from can simplify flattening the hierarchy.

• File System Walks: In applications that navigate file systems, yield from can flatten directory structures while processing each file or folder individually.

• Complex Aggregations: When dealing with recursive data aggregation (e.g., multi-level financial summaries), yield from can streamline data collection across nested structures.

Conclusion

Recursive methods in Django can be challenging, especially when they span multiple models and require memory efficiency. By using generators, you can turn memory-intensive, list-based methods into on-demand, efficient solutions that yield results as they’re available.

Using best practices like yield from, tracking visited sources, and optimizing database queries, you can make your recursive methods robust, scalable, and maintainable. Next time you encounter a complex recursive challenge, try using these techniques—you’ll likely find your code more manageable and performant.